similarminds.com
Ad note: I don't control the ad inventory so be careful about accidentally clicking on a deceptive ad.
Prefer no ads? Get a one year SimilarMinds ad-free pass
Articles / Data

SimilarMinds historical personality data

Indie Rock Interest and Personality

How does indie-rock liking relate to other questionnaire dimensions, overall and within each recorded gender? The historical measure was a single item about liking the band The Pixies. It is a narrow music-preference proxy, not a comprehensive measure of indie-rock taste.

Artistic and intellectual interests stand out

Combined-sample high/low gaps are +18.2 points for artistic interests (0.76 SD) and +12.7 for intellectual interests (0.72 SD). Both exceed the substantial-gap screen in men and women separately.

Some smaller gender differences

The intellectual-interest association is stronger descriptively in women (r = +.271) than men (+.213). Artistic-interest associations are +.236 and +.201. These differences are descriptive, not formal tests of a gender interaction.

A further high/low association

Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes has a +12.3-point combined-sample gap (0.51 SD), passing the screen overall and in women, but not in men. This scale blends behavior and attitudes; it is not a clinical substance-use measure.

The item is dated and narrow

These preferences were recorded in 2008-2011 and refer to one band. Associations may reflect musical exposure, age/cohort, cultural background, and broad response tendencies. They should not be generalized to every indie-rock listener today.

Diverging bars compare high-minus-low score gaps across everyone, men, and women. Exact estimates appear in the tables below.
Nine largest personality-score gaps across the three views. The display includes effects below the substantial-gap screen.

Everyone

135,982profiles
8,238high scorers (75-100)
60,113low scorers (0-25)

3 of 38 personality dimensions pass the substantial-gap screen; 0 pass the continuous-correlation screen. Mean focal score: 33.8/100.

Passing gaps: Intellectual interests +12.7 points (+0.72 SD); Artistic interests/creativity +18.2 points (+0.76 SD); Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes +12.3 points (+0.51 SD).

Strongest Continuous Associations

Top eight personality dimensions by absolute full-adjusted correlation. Ranking does not imply that every association is substantial.

Personality dimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gap
Intellectual interests+0.243+0.248+0.247+12.7+0.72
Artistic interests/creativity+0.224+0.223+0.222+18.2+0.76
Humanitarian concern+0.147+0.148+0.148+8.1+0.43
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.127+0.126+0.125+8.1+0.37
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.127+0.125+0.124+12.3+0.51
Orderliness-0.119-0.120-0.119-7.6-0.41
Preference for familiarity-0.115-0.114-0.113-7.0-0.39
Thrill seeking+0.104+0.102+0.101+7.3+0.35
All 38 personality dimensions: correlations and high/low gaps
DimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rr: half Ar: half BLow meanHigh meanAdjusted gapSD gapGap: half AGap: half BGap screen
Intellectual interests+0.243+0.248+0.247+0.246+0.24848.361.3+12.7+0.72+12.8+12.5Pass
Artistic interests/creativity+0.224+0.223+0.222+0.220+0.22351.269.6+18.2+0.76+18.0+18.4Pass
Humanitarian concern+0.147+0.148+0.148+0.143+0.15256.464.5+8.1+0.43+7.8+8.4Below screen
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.127+0.126+0.125+0.123+0.12643.251.5+8.1+0.37+8.2+8.0Below screen
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.127+0.125+0.124+0.125+0.12340.853.6+12.3+0.51+12.3+12.3Pass
Orderliness-0.119-0.120-0.119-0.119-0.11852.444.8-7.6-0.41-7.5-7.6Below screen
Preference for familiarity-0.115-0.114-0.113-0.117-0.11050.143.0-7.0-0.39-7.1-6.8Below screen
Thrill seeking+0.104+0.102+0.101+0.104+0.09745.653.3+7.3+0.35+7.7+6.9Below screen
Desire for children/family-0.102-0.101-0.097-0.100-0.09560.352.7-7.2-0.33-7.2-7.3Below screen
Religious faith-0.092-0.089-0.087-0.089-0.08446.335.3-10.3-0.34-10.3-10.2Below screen
Importance of money-0.077-0.078-0.079-0.075-0.08252.247.0-5.3-0.25-5.0-5.7Below screen
Desire to be different+0.073+0.070+0.068+0.071+0.06454.560.9+6.1+0.32+6.3+5.9Below screen
Need for support/nurturance+0.060+0.058+0.059+0.062+0.05641.343.4+2.2+0.12+2.2+2.1Below screen
Cautiousness-0.059-0.058-0.058-0.056-0.05958.855.0-3.7-0.21-3.7-3.8Below screen
Resisting subordination+0.055+0.056+0.054+0.054+0.05554.359.0+4.7+0.26+4.6+4.8Below screen
Aversion to adult responsibilities+0.059+0.055+0.054+0.055+0.05344.248.2+3.7+0.19+3.9+3.6Below screen
Self-rated competence/superiority+0.056+0.055+0.054+0.051+0.05747.449.6+1.9+0.11+1.8+2.0Below screen
Self-rated attractiveness+0.055+0.052+0.050+0.046+0.05459.063.4+4.0+0.21+3.8+4.2Below screen
Sexual interest+0.047+0.046+0.045+0.047+0.04457.862.3+4.0+0.20+4.0+4.0Below screen
Self-rated financial wealth+0.044+0.042+0.041+0.045+0.03833.133.8+0.6+0.04+0.6+0.6Below screen
Disclosure/outgoingness+0.037+0.039+0.040+0.040+0.04054.257.1+2.9+0.16+3.1+2.7Below screen
Keeping promises-0.043-0.040-0.039-0.039-0.03960.357.6-2.6-0.16-2.7-2.5Below screen
Self-rated excess weight-0.044-0.041-0.038-0.034-0.04245.741.7-3.6-0.14-3.4-3.8Below screen
Saving/spending control-0.037-0.037-0.037-0.041-0.03253.748.7-4.7-0.22-5.4-4.0Below screen
Enjoying conflict+0.037+0.036+0.036+0.039+0.03239.542.3+2.6+0.13+3.2+1.9Below screen
Emotional calm+0.029+0.034+0.034+0.034+0.03449.850.6+0.8+0.04+0.6+1.0Below screen
Accepting help-0.032-0.034-0.033-0.038-0.02952.850.7-2.1-0.11-2.2-2.0Below screen
Romantic-relationship orientation+0.033+0.031+0.031+0.035+0.02753.055.3+2.0+0.10+2.4+1.6Below screen
Keeping emotional distance+0.031+0.028+0.027+0.028+0.02644.246.5+2.1+0.10+2.1+2.2Below screen
Suspicion of others-0.022-0.025-0.026-0.023-0.02951.351.5+0.0+0.00+0.6-0.5Below screen
Distress at being ignored+0.026+0.021+0.020+0.025+0.01543.644.9+1.0+0.05+1.4+0.6Below screen
Expensive consumption+0.021+0.021+0.020+0.024+0.01734.535.8+1.2+0.06+1.6+0.8Below screen
Exercise+0.021+0.020+0.019+0.018+0.02053.755.0+1.1+0.05+1.1+1.2Below screen
Desire to lead/control-0.016-0.019-0.019-0.015-0.02250.949.2-1.9-0.09-1.6-2.2Below screen
Importance of physical beauty+0.022+0.020+0.018+0.019+0.01848.049.5+1.3+0.07+1.3+1.4Below screen
Admitting mistakes+0.013+0.018+0.017+0.015+0.01957.158.6+1.6+0.09+1.6+1.6Below screen
Putting others first-0.019-0.015-0.013-0.014-0.01260.159.0-0.8-0.04-0.8-0.8Below screen
Work orientation-0.006-0.006-0.007-0.010-0.00450.349.3-1.2-0.06-1.3-1.0Below screen
The other two single-item measures
MeasureRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gapGap screen
Same-gender romantic attraction+0.129+0.126+0.124+10.0+0.38Below screen
Self-rated relative height+0.046+0.047+0.047+3.5+0.13Below screen

Split-half counts: A high 4,137, low 30,026; B high 4,101, low 30,087.

Men

54,488profiles
3,405high scorers (75-100)
24,563low scorers (0-25)

2 of 38 personality dimensions pass the substantial-gap screen; 0 pass the continuous-correlation screen. Mean focal score: 33.7/100.

Passing gaps: Intellectual interests +11.1 points (+0.64 SD); Artistic interests/creativity +17.5 points (+0.73 SD).

Strongest Continuous Associations

Top eight personality dimensions by absolute full-adjusted correlation. Ranking does not imply that every association is substantial.

Personality dimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gap
Intellectual interests+0.214+0.213+0.213+11.1+0.64
Artistic interests/creativity+0.203+0.203+0.201+17.5+0.73
Humanitarian concern+0.133+0.133+0.132+6.9+0.35
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.115+0.111+0.110+11.8+0.48
Orderliness-0.105-0.110-0.110-7.1-0.39
Preference for familiarity-0.099-0.098-0.097-6.3-0.36
Importance of money-0.094-0.097-0.097-6.9-0.32
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.083+0.082+0.081+5.2+0.23
All 38 personality dimensions: correlations and high/low gaps
DimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rr: half Ar: half BLow meanHigh meanAdjusted gapSD gapGap: half AGap: half BGap screen
Intellectual interests+0.214+0.213+0.213+0.211+0.21453.765.0+11.1+0.64+11.1+11.1Pass
Artistic interests/creativity+0.203+0.203+0.201+0.201+0.20250.368.0+17.5+0.73+17.6+17.4Pass
Humanitarian concern+0.133+0.133+0.132+0.123+0.14254.261.1+6.9+0.35+6.2+7.5Below screen
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.115+0.111+0.110+0.116+0.10443.355.6+11.8+0.48+11.7+11.9Below screen
Orderliness-0.105-0.110-0.110-0.108-0.11250.443.6-7.1-0.39-7.0-7.1Below screen
Preference for familiarity-0.099-0.098-0.097-0.101-0.09348.542.1-6.3-0.36-6.4-6.2Below screen
Importance of money-0.094-0.097-0.097-0.093-0.10153.346.6-6.9-0.32-6.6-7.2Below screen
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.083+0.082+0.081+0.079+0.08344.049.3+5.2+0.23+5.0+5.4Below screen
Need for support/nurturance+0.069+0.073+0.073+0.075+0.07140.443.4+3.3+0.18+3.1+3.5Below screen
Desire for children/family-0.067-0.070-0.067-0.071-0.06256.251.0-5.2-0.25-5.1-5.4Below screen
Religious faith-0.066-0.066-0.064-0.068-0.06043.134.1-8.7-0.29-9.0-8.5Below screen
Romantic-relationship orientation+0.063+0.063+0.062+0.068+0.05552.856.7+3.8+0.19+4.8+2.8Below screen
Desire to lead/control-0.053-0.055-0.054-0.051-0.05754.750.8-3.9-0.19-3.5-4.4Below screen
Thrill seeking+0.053+0.055+0.054+0.061+0.04751.255.7+4.6+0.22+5.4+3.7Below screen
Aversion to adult responsibilities+0.051+0.053+0.053+0.049+0.05644.848.6+3.9+0.20+3.5+4.4Below screen
Resisting subordination+0.048+0.048+0.047+0.046+0.04855.160.2+5.0+0.27+4.8+5.2Below screen
Saving/spending control-0.051-0.047-0.046-0.055-0.03754.148.2-5.4-0.25-6.5-4.3Below screen
Self-rated attractiveness+0.049+0.047+0.046+0.043+0.04956.259.9+3.5+0.18+3.4+3.6Below screen
Self-rated financial wealth+0.041+0.046+0.045+0.047+0.04334.835.2+0.7+0.04+0.6+0.8Below screen
Keeping promises-0.042-0.045-0.044-0.047-0.04160.357.5-3.0-0.18-3.3-2.8Below screen
Self-rated excess weight-0.032-0.039-0.037-0.037-0.03641.338.8-3.0-0.12-2.9-3.1Below screen
Desire to be different+0.033+0.036+0.034+0.038+0.02955.659.9+4.4+0.24+4.8+4.0Below screen
Suspicion of others-0.035-0.033-0.034-0.023-0.04552.552.1-0.3-0.01+0.7-1.2Below screen
Disclosure/outgoingness+0.034+0.033+0.033+0.035+0.03152.455.5+3.0+0.16+3.3+2.6Below screen
Cautiousness-0.032-0.032-0.032-0.028-0.03758.355.8-2.5-0.14-2.4-2.6Below screen
Enjoying conflict+0.027+0.029+0.029+0.036+0.02243.445.9+2.8+0.13+3.7+1.8Below screen
Work orientation-0.022-0.027-0.027-0.031-0.02349.847.7-2.5-0.13-2.5-2.5Below screen
Keeping emotional distance+0.027+0.026+0.025+0.027+0.02343.745.9+2.1+0.10+1.9+2.3Below screen
Distress at being ignored+0.022+0.022+0.022+0.026+0.01743.344.6+1.3+0.06+2.1+0.5Below screen
Self-rated competence/superiority+0.023+0.021+0.021+0.021+0.02151.251.7+0.4+0.02+0.6+0.2Below screen
Exercise-0.019-0.017-0.018-0.014-0.02258.857.4-1.2-0.05-0.6-1.8Below screen
Emotional calm+0.013+0.013+0.013+0.009+0.01856.655.9-0.6-0.03-0.7-0.4Below screen
Accepting help-0.013-0.012-0.012-0.014-0.01052.251.2-0.9-0.04-0.8-0.9Below screen
Importance of physical beauty+0.013+0.012+0.011+0.015+0.00648.549.5+0.9+0.05+1.1+0.7Below screen
Admitting mistakes+0.017+0.011+0.010+0.007+0.01458.259.7+1.0+0.06+0.9+1.1Below screen
Sexual interest-0.003-0.009-0.009-0.009-0.00961.462.7+0.8+0.04+0.9+0.6Below screen
Putting others first+0.005+0.006+0.007+0.001+0.01357.357.2+0.0+0.00-0.1+0.1Below screen
Expensive consumption+0.007+0.005+0.005+0.009-0.00038.038.6+0.5+0.02+0.7+0.2Below screen
The other two single-item measures
MeasureRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gapGap screen
Same-gender romantic attraction+0.072+0.072+0.070+4.1+0.16Below screen
Self-rated relative height+0.040+0.042+0.042+3.7+0.15Below screen

Split-half counts: A high 1,712, low 12,291; B high 1,693, low 12,272.

Women

81,494profiles
4,833high scorers (75-100)
35,550low scorers (0-25)

3 of 38 personality dimensions pass the substantial-gap screen; 1 pass the continuous-correlation screen. Mean focal score: 33.9/100.

Passing gaps: Intellectual interests +13.8 points (+0.81 SD); Artistic interests/creativity +18.6 points (+0.78 SD); Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes +12.6 points (+0.53 SD).

Strongest Continuous Associations

Top eight personality dimensions by absolute full-adjusted correlation. Ranking does not imply that every association is substantial.

Personality dimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gap
Intellectual interests+0.275+0.273+0.271+13.8+0.81
Artistic interests/creativity+0.239+0.237+0.236+18.6+0.78
Humanitarian concern+0.158+0.159+0.159+9.0+0.49
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.157+0.156+0.155+10.2+0.46
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.137+0.136+0.134+12.6+0.53
Thrill seeking+0.142+0.134+0.132+9.3+0.44
Orderliness-0.130-0.126-0.125-7.9-0.43
Preference for familiarity-0.125-0.125-0.124-7.4-0.41
All 38 personality dimensions: correlations and high/low gaps
DimensionRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rr: half Ar: half BLow meanHigh meanAdjusted gapSD gapGap: half AGap: half BGap screen
Intellectual interests+0.275+0.273+0.271+0.270+0.27144.658.7+13.8+0.81+14.0+13.6Pass
Artistic interests/creativity+0.239+0.237+0.236+0.233+0.23851.970.8+18.6+0.78+18.2+19.0Pass
Humanitarian concern+0.158+0.159+0.159+0.158+0.16057.966.9+9.0+0.49+8.9+9.1Below screen
Mystical/paranormal orientation+0.157+0.156+0.155+0.154+0.15642.653.0+10.2+0.46+10.5+9.8Below screen
Alcohol/tobacco use and attitudes+0.137+0.136+0.134+0.132+0.13639.152.2+12.6+0.53+12.7+12.6Pass
Thrill seeking+0.142+0.134+0.132+0.134+0.13041.751.7+9.3+0.44+9.3+9.2Below screen
Orderliness-0.130-0.126-0.125-0.127-0.12253.845.6-7.9-0.43-7.9-7.9Below screen
Preference for familiarity-0.125-0.125-0.124-0.127-0.12051.343.7-7.4-0.41-7.6-7.3Below screen
Desire for children/family-0.127-0.121-0.117-0.119-0.11663.253.9-8.6-0.39-8.6-8.6Below screen
Religious faith-0.110-0.105-0.102-0.103-0.10148.536.1-11.4-0.38-11.3-11.5Below screen
Desire to be different+0.100+0.093+0.091+0.094+0.08853.861.6+7.3+0.38+7.4+7.2Below screen
Sexual interest+0.081+0.082+0.080+0.083+0.07755.462.1+6.2+0.31+6.1+6.3Below screen
Self-rated competence/superiority+0.080+0.077+0.076+0.072+0.08044.848.0+3.0+0.17+2.7+3.3Below screen
Cautiousness-0.077-0.076-0.075-0.075-0.07559.254.4-4.6-0.26-4.6-4.7Below screen
Importance of money-0.065-0.065-0.065-0.062-0.06951.547.4-4.3-0.21-3.9-4.6Below screen
Resisting subordination+0.061+0.061+0.059+0.059+0.05953.758.3+4.5+0.26+4.5+4.6Below screen
Aversion to adult responsibilities+0.064+0.056+0.055+0.060+0.05043.947.9+3.6+0.19+4.1+3.1Below screen
Self-rated attractiveness+0.060+0.056+0.053+0.048+0.05861.065.8+4.4+0.23+4.2+4.5Below screen
Need for support/nurturance+0.053+0.048+0.049+0.052+0.04641.943.5+1.4+0.08+1.6+1.1Below screen
Emotional calm+0.045+0.049+0.048+0.051+0.04545.246.8+1.8+0.10+1.5+2.1Below screen
Accepting help-0.045-0.048-0.047-0.054-0.04153.250.3-3.0-0.15-3.2-2.8Below screen
Disclosure/outgoingness+0.039+0.044+0.044+0.043+0.04555.558.2+2.9+0.16+2.9+2.8Below screen
Exercise+0.049+0.045+0.044+0.039+0.04850.253.3+2.8+0.12+2.2+3.3Below screen
Enjoying conflict+0.047+0.040+0.041+0.041+0.03936.939.7+2.5+0.12+2.9+2.0Below screen
Self-rated excess weight-0.054-0.042-0.039-0.033-0.04548.843.7-4.0-0.15-3.7-4.3Below screen
Self-rated financial wealth+0.047+0.039+0.039+0.043+0.03431.932.7+0.6+0.03+0.6+0.5Below screen
Keeping promises-0.043-0.036-0.035-0.033-0.03760.357.6-2.4-0.14-2.4-2.4Below screen
Expensive consumption+0.033+0.032+0.031+0.034+0.02932.033.8+1.7+0.09+2.3+1.1Below screen
Saving/spending control-0.028-0.031-0.030-0.032-0.02853.349.0-4.3-0.19-4.7-3.8Below screen
Keeping emotional distance+0.033+0.029+0.028+0.028+0.02844.546.8+2.2+0.10+2.3+2.1Below screen
Putting others first-0.037-0.030-0.027-0.025-0.02962.060.2-1.3-0.08-1.3-1.4Below screen
Importance of physical beauty+0.028+0.025+0.024+0.022+0.02647.749.5+1.6+0.09+1.4+1.8Below screen
Admitting mistakes+0.011+0.022+0.021+0.021+0.02256.357.9+2.0+0.11+2.1+1.9Below screen
Suspicion of others-0.014-0.020-0.020-0.022-0.01850.551.1+0.2+0.01+0.6-0.1Below screen
Distress at being ignored+0.029+0.021+0.020+0.025+0.01443.845.2+0.8+0.04+1.0+0.6Below screen
Romantic-relationship orientation+0.013+0.010+0.010+0.011+0.00853.254.3+0.8+0.04+0.7+0.8Below screen
Work orientation+0.004+0.007+0.007+0.004+0.00950.650.4-0.2-0.01-0.5+0.1Below screen
Desire to lead/control+0.010+0.006+0.005+0.009+0.00248.248.1-0.5-0.02-0.2-0.7Below screen
The other two single-item measures
MeasureRaw rAge-adjusted rFull rAdjusted gapSD gapGap screen
Same-gender romantic attraction+0.168+0.163+0.162+14.1+0.54Pass
Self-rated relative height+0.053+0.050+0.050+3.4+0.13Below screen

Split-half counts: A high 2,425, low 17,735; B high 2,408, low 17,815.

How to Read These Comparisons

High and low are score bands, not population percentiles. High means 75-100 on the focal item, low means 0-25. Intermediate scores are omitted only from the high/low contrasts; correlations use every retained profile.

Raw r is the Pearson correlation before adjustment. Age-adjusted r removes quadratic approximate age and recorded gender, with gender-by-age interactions. Full r also removes relationship-category terms and gender-by-category interactions. The men-only and women-only fits are separate and adjust age and status without a gender term. Status may be intertwined with the focal measure; neither adjustment identifies a causal effect.

Adjusted gap is the high-minus-low difference in mean outcome residuals after the full adjustment, in 0-100 score points. It is not a percentage increase. SD gap divides that gap by the outcome's SD in the entire relevant gender cohort, not just the two extreme groups. It is not conventional pooled-group Cohen's d. Raw low/high means remain available in the complete tables.

Substantial-gap screen: at least 500 people per side in each deterministic split half; |SD gap| at least 0.50 overall and 0.40 in each half, with the same direction. The separate continuous screen is |full r| at least .25 overall and .23 in both halves, with the same direction. These are effect-size filters, not significance tests, and are not universal cutoffs for importance. Both halves are from the same historical sample, not independent external validation.

Coverage: 135,982 adult profiles with recorded male/female metadata and approximate age 18-80, from 253,717 valid stored profiles. The common cohort excludes missing or implausible adult age, missing male/female metadata, invalid/all-50 profiles, and split-by-gender-by-age-band-by-status cells below 30 people (259 otherwise eligible adult profiles). No other gender categories can be examined from this extract. All 40 other stored dimensions are retained for each focal item, including 38 personality dimensions and the other two single-item measures.

Limits: self-selected historical users, self-report measurement, potential shared response tendencies, and social-network dependence. Birth year may have been inferred from graduation; its provenance is not marked. Relationship metadata may have updated independently of testing. The wealth, weight, height, competence, and attractiveness scores are self-ratings, not objective measurements. The attractiveness scale partly refers to opposite-sex attention, which complicates attraction-group interpretation. No correction for a broad response factor is performed here.

Historical tests: April 26, 2008 to October 19, 2011. Aggregate-only extraction; no names, contact details or individual answers exported.

Download all 120 comparisons for this article (CSV)

Related Research and Tests